Above: Justice Jester during NYC Shut It Down’s stand up comedy event on April 11. (WNV/Ashoka Jegroo)
One of New York City’s most active anti-police brutality groups now uses stand-up comedy as well as direct action to raise consciousness.
On April 11, the group “NYC Shut It Down” held an event in Brooklyn called “Stand Up, Don’t Shoot” featuring spoken word poetry and comedy from the activists themselves. The group, also called the “Grand Central Crew,” is known for their weekly protests at Grand Central Terminal, occupying big retail stores, and recently confronting City Council Speaker Melissa Mark-Viverito and asking her to defend her calls for more cops.
“We’re here to bring some light and levity to our dark and tragic times right now using art and comedy to affect social change,” Elsa Waithe, stand-up comedian and member of NYC Shut It Down, said. “Sometimes you can supercede someone’s defenses with laughter. People laugh at things for two reasons: because they understand and you’ve talked about something personal to them that they can’t talk about; or they laugh because they feel included, they feel in on the joke. So sometimes it’s easier to discuss difficult topics in that way.”
Throughout the night, audience members in the back room of the Inkwell Jazz and Comedy Club in Bedford-Stuyvesant chuckled and howled at jokes on activist topics ranging from getting arrested as protests to cat-sitting for gentrifiers to everyday experiences of racism. The topic of one specific set of jokes, the City Council’s proposal to increase the size of the New York Police Department, was especially pertinent for NYC Shut It Down.
“The NYPD wants to add 1,000 new police officers,” Waithe joked while on stage, “which I think is okay if we maybe got rid of 1,000 old police officers.”
Recently, M.J. Williams, another member of NYC Shut It Down, made the news for asking Council Speaker Viverito about her push for more cops during the New York Law School legislative breakfast on Friday.
“How can you defend adding 1,000 more police officers before the NYPD is drastically reformed?” Williams asked. “And how will more cops lead to systemic changes and not more tragedies?”
Video of Mark-Viverito answering the question spread online shortly afterward. And though the council speaker answered that she thought that both reform and “more resources” were needed for the NYPD to do “effective community policing,” Williams felt unsatisfied by her answer.
“I found it to be rambling. I found it to be unconvincing,” Williams said. “She relied on, I think, the crutch of people being afraid and people needing to be comforted by there being more cops out there.”