Chelsea Manning Returns To Jail In ‘Unprecedented’ Ruling

| Resist!

Above: U.S. Army whistleblower Chelsea Manning addresses reporters outside the Albert Bryan U.S federal courthouse with attorney Moira Meltzer-Cohen on May 16, 2019 in Alexandria, Virginia. Photo byWin McNamee for Getty Images.

In a move press freedom advocates and progressive critics decried as an “outrageous” and “unprecedented” escalation of a prolonged government harassment campaign, a federal judge on Thursday ordered U.S. Army whistleblower Chelsea Manning back to jail for refusing to testify before a secretive grand jury and imposed a $500 fine for every day she is in custody after 30 days.

If Manning refuses to comply with the grand jury subpoena after 60 days, the fine will increase to $1,000 per day.

During a court hearing on Thursday, Manning told Judge Anthony Trenga that she has no intention of giving in to government pressure.

“I would rather starve to death than to change my opinion in this regard,” said Manning. “And when I say that, I mean that quite literally.”

Manning’s imprisonment Thursday came exactly one week after she was released following a 62-day stint in jail—including a month in solitary confinement—for refusing to testify before a grand jury that, as the Guardian reported, “is presumed to relate to the criminal prosecution” of WikiLeaks founder and publisher Julian Assange, who is currently fighting the Trump administration’s attempt to extradite him to the United States.

“This is unprecedented,” read a tweet from Manning’s official Twitter account.

Moira Meltzer-Cohen, an attorney for Manning, said in a statement Thursday that while she is “disappointed” with the judge’s decision, she expects “it will be exactly as coercive as the previous sanction—which is to say not at all.”

“In 2010 Chelsea made a principled decision to let the world see the true nature modern asymmetric warfare,” said Meltzer-Cohen. “It is telling that the United States has always been more concerned with the disclosure of those documents than with the damning substance of the disclosures.”

“The American government relies on the informed consent of the governed, and the free press is the vigorous mechanism to keep us informed. It is a point of pride for this administration to be publicly hostile to the press,” she added. “It is up to the press to stand up for themselves, to stand up for the practice of journalism, and to stand up for Chelsea in the same manner she has consistently stood up for the press.”

  • Pat moore

    Kudos to the courage and commitment of Chelsea and her attorney.
    No more US imperislism

  • Guy

    There you have it ,in the land of the free and spreading democratic principles across the world.NOT.

  • John Chadwick

    Shouldn’t we be grateful that Judge Trenga didn’t sentence Chelsea to be burned at the stake? That’s the quality of ‘justice’ we can expect nowadays…


    A citizen has told an authority figure “You are behaving in a sinister and illegal way” and the sold-out judge, furious and in a childish tantrum, piles on. It takes guts to stand up to fascist power the way Chelsea is doing. She is our Sophie Scholl.

  • Jon

    THIS is what principled behavior looks like!

  • Werner Rhein

    This is equal to Soviet Union Stalin area oppression. Anyone who is not in line with the capitalistic criminal rulers are to be incarcerated and charged with fines on top of it. That is the land of the free this days.