#SandySpeaks: ‘I’m Here To Change History’

| Resist!

Sandra Bland (ABC7)

As I watched 28-year-old Sandra Bland assert her humanity by refusing to roll over and play slave for white Officer Brian Encinia, who had grown increasingly agitated by that refusal, the words of Zora Neale Hurston rang in my head through the numbness: “If you are silent about your pain, they’ll kill you and say you enjoyed it.”

On July 10, Bland was ready. If she was to die, if she was to feel the blows of brutality on her brown skin, no one would be able to say that she enjoyed it.

Some may say that Bland foreshadowed her own death in Texas. Her Facebook cover photo—highlighting the hypocrisy of state-sanctioned anti-black terrorism—shows a caricature of Dylann Roof eating the Burger King burger his arresting officers bought him after he was captured for murdering nine people at Emanuel African Methodist Episcopal Church in Charleston, S.C.

Beside him in the patrol car sits a black man, handcuffed, bloody and bruised. Her profile picture boldly states, “Now legalize being Black in America,” a reference to the Supreme Court’s landmark ruling that made marriage equality legal in all U.S. states while black people are still being killed relentlessly, oftentimes with their killers fully protected by the laws of those same states.

She knew that we lived in a world where that could be any of us walking around in this skin at any moment. She knew the stakes were high when she was pulled over. She knew her life was on the line because she, like all of us, had seen it so many times before. She, like so many of us, understood that we’re only one bullet or choke hold away from being the next hashtag.

And she was ready.

Officer Brian Encinia: You mind putting out your cigarette, please?
Brown:
 I’m in my car. Why do I have to put out my cigarette?
Encinia: Well, you can step on out now.
Brown:
 I don’t have to step out of my car.
Encinia:
 Step out of the car. [He opens her car door.] Brown: No … you don’t have the right.
Encinia: Step out of the car. … I do have the right. Now, step out or I will remove you.
Brown: I refuse to talk to you other than to identify myself. … I’m getting removed for a failure …
Encinia: Step out or I will remove you. I am giving you a lawful order. Get out of the car now.
Brown: And I’m calling my lawyer.
Encinia:
 I’m going to yank you out.

From there, Encinia grows increasingly violent, shedding his syrupy Texas drawl like a snake’s skin. After threatening to “light [her] up” with his Taser, Bland steps out of the car, calling him the coward that he is.

She knew the drill. She knew to narrate everything as it happened. She clearly states whenever Encinia pulls her roughly, when he twists her wrist, when he throws her to the ground and knocks her head to the pavement.

When she screams that she has epilepsy, Encinia sneers, “Good.” Bland continues to say that she can’t wait to take him to court.

Three days later, she would be dead, with authorities claiming that she hanged herself in her Waller County jail cell with a plastic bag.

While Bland’s alleged suicide is highly questionable and the focus of growing protests, MSNBC, CNN and Fox legal analyst Eric L. Welch Guster of Guster Law Firm confirmed for The Root what many of us watching the video already knew: She never should have been arrested in the first place.

“This video shows that Sandra Bland was wrongfully arrested,” Guster said. “If Encinia had followed proper protocol and procedures, Sandra Bland would be alive today.

“She didn’t have to put out the cigarette,” Guster continued. “There was no reason to ask her that. It wasn’t a lawful order for her to get out. She complied with his request for identification and was about to sign the ticket.

“Having a ‘smart mouth’ is not a reason to arrest someone,” Guster added. “She never threatened him in any way. He wouldn’t tell her why she was being arrested because he didn’t have a valid reason to arrest.”

No, he didn’t. And through her arrest and subsequent death, Bland has emerged as a martyr, illuminating police violence against black women in a way that is finally resonating across the country.

Black women have fought to be central to a movement that has historically marginalized us and continues to do so. We have told the Obama administration #WhyWeCantWait. We have urged the world to #SayHerName. Now more and more people are doing just that.

The day after Bland’s death, 18-year-old Kindra Chapman allegedly committed suicide in her jail cell in Homewood, Ala.—also, allegedly, by hanging—after being arrested on a trumped-up charge. There hasn’t been a lot of coverage of her case, and for some reason the hashtags haven’t flowed. Jefferson County, Ala., District Attorney Brandon Falls says that he is ready to release the preliminary autopsy findings, but he hasn’t been able to reach her family.

From what we know of Bland, she would have demanded justice for Chapman.

During the same week of Bland’s and Chapman’s deaths, we celebrated the birthdays of revolutionaries Ida B. Wells and Assata Shakur. It is also the week that Black Lives Matter co-founder Patrisse Cullors and protesters Tia Oso and Ashley Yates shut down Netroots Nation when they refused to genuflect at the altar of the Democratic Party’s racial cowardice.

Bland, who made it clear that she wanted the next generation to understand their “history and survival,” would have supported their speaking truth to power, just as she did before she was silenced, and just as Wells and Shakur did before them.

In many ways, our responsibility as writers during these times of relentless police violence is to record history, to provide a voice for those who are no longer here to speak for themselves. We use our platforms to that end day in and day out, sometimes struggling with what to say—again—and hoping that it’s powerful enough to play a role in raising awareness and finding a justice that always seems to elude black people in this country.

This time, the most powerful thing we can do is pass the mic to Sandra Bland herself:

“Hey, y’all. I am getting ready for bed,” she said at the beginning of her first #SandySpeaks video. “And before I go to sleep, there has been something big, really heavy on my mind. A seed that I feel God has truly planted in my life. Work that he has set for me to do, a message that he has for me to get out. So before I go to sleep on today, January 14, 2015, I wanted to make this video message and plant my seed of #SandySpeaks …

“Now would be the perfect time, if you feel like your child might be too young, to kind of start opening the door to them, and educating them on how to interact with police. It’s never too early, in all honesty … and if you’re a cop and you’re watching this, here’s your chance to say something to these kids …

“It’s time, y’all. It’s time. This thing that I’m holding in my hand, this telephone, this camera, social media is powerful. If we want to change, we can truly make it happen. We sit out here and we talk about we need the next so-and-so and this and that; no, you don’t. Start in your own home. Start with you. You start being that person that wants to make that change.

“You know, it’s funny … whoever’s watching this … I’m probably going to get a few of those Michael Jackson ‘Oh, I want to make that change’ comments, but laugh all you want to, say what you want, but I’m here to change history.”

We hear you, Sandra.

It may not be in the way that she thought she would, but she has, indeed, changed history. And as we continue to fight for justice for her, I also salute her.

Thank you, Sandra, for your voice. Thank you for bearing witness.

Thank you for not being silent about your pain and for making sure that no one could ever say that you enjoyed it.

Now, for Sandra Bland’s mother, Geneva Reed-Veal, and for many supporters around the country, “This means war.”

  • “This means war”? But what does that mean exactly? Are you going to take up arms? Good luck with that.

    I don’t know what happened to this poor woman in jail. I do know the cop was being an asshole, he was wrong, and there’s no defending him. I also know Sandra Bland was foolish to challenge him. In those situations, you will always lose.

    Of course he should never have stopped her. It was a power play. Abusive thugs love to lord their power over other people. But getting into a confrontation with an abusive thug, one in uniform, no less, is foolish. And guess what — he did have the right to order her out of her car. She picked the wrong time to make a point.

    I hope he’s prosecuted for his behavior, though I doubt he will be. And I hope we find out what happened to Sandra Bland. She should never have been pulled over to begin with. But let’s be careful which examples we hold up as illustrative. Nobody, of any color, should behave toward a cop at a traffic stop the way she did. You will only lose.

  • AnotherNamVet

    A black woman gets arrested by a racist cop for exercising the right to freely express herself and is later murdered while in custody at the county jail. A violent white man kills nine black people at a church and gets rewarded with a Burger King’s combo meal while in custody at the police station… and the best you can come up with is to preach about good manners to the dead black woman?

  • You have chosen to misconstrue what I wrote.

    This isn’t about “the best I can come up with.” It’s about staying alive. I already said, repeatedly, that the cop was wrong and that I hope he get prosecuted. Cold comfort. Because Sandra Bland is dead.

    And you have no idea if she was murdered in jail. The fact that there are so many people murdered in jail doesn’t automatically mean that she also was. You’re not doing any good by making claims you can’t prove. And I don’t know what that racist freak Dylan Roof has to do with anything.

  • didactic1

    Agree. The fAct she was humiliated on a day that was supposed to ttransitto a better stage may have triggered massive depression, whilecop didn’t know that his aggression would likely have causedhumiliation to most people. Unacceptable. Sue him and county.

  • didactic1

    Murder hasn’t been shown. Negligence likely. Overcharge and cop walks and county escapes paying.

  • didactic1

    The situation sucks and is impossible to view without anger. I agree w you but understand guy you replied to.

  • didactic1

    Roof won’t enjoy a meal again.

  • It’s impossible for any sentient being not be angry, not only over this but over all the people who are abused by Police State USA. We all know that black people, Hispanic people, and poor white people — the disenfranchised in general — are abused in this country, all the time, every day.

    I live in Baltimore, where Freddie Gray was killed. I think the cops who caused his death, however indirectly, should be held accountable. It’s at the very least manslaughter if not murder. I marched and shouted till I was hoarse. But I don’t stand on any high horse, as I believe AnotherNamVet was trying to do.

    I think we damage our cause — the cause of justice — when we make wild claims. God knows there’s enough injustice in the world as it is without making stuff up.

  • Dawn Wolfson

    Agree that it’s not smart to stand up to a power crazy bully like that, but on the other hand if people don’t start standing up to these guys, things will just get worse. As for your comments below, agree we can’t at this point prove that she was murdered. I believe she was, but we need to wait for the facts to come out. There is way too much speculation flying around (but then that’s pretty much standard operating procedure any time something like this happens).

  • Dawn, yes, of course we must stand up for ourselves. I run a civil liberties watchdog site called TSA News Blog, where I advocate standing up for ourselves to a fare thee well. I also believe in rational action.

    There’s a time and a place to stand up for oneself and a time and a place not to — unless one wants to become a martyr. Which is all well and good — I wouldn’t deny anyone the right to do that. I just think that to risk getting oneself injured or killed without first thinking through the consequences isn’t a good route to follow.

    I want people to come out alive after dealing with a cop. Alive and unharmed (at least physically).

  • kevinzeese

    It is certainly not blaming Sandra to point out the risks in dealing with police, especially if they show a power abuse streak as this officer did. The Ten Rules for Black Youth in Police Encounters, https://www.popularresistance.org/ten-rules-for-black-youth-in-police-encounters/, are consistent with what Lisa says. In fact, these rules apply to everyone but especially to people from communities of color. These are ugly times and too many police show a tendancy toward abusing the power and police violence.

  • Dawn Wolfson

    Agreed, not blaming her, and it is dangerous to stand up to police, even passively. There was an article by Leonard Pitts Jr. in today’s paper about a white man who got beaten and had a police dog sicced on him after he was subdued, so it’s certainly not just a black issue, or just a matter of people resisting. I’m just saying in a general way, that if we as a population don’t start standing against police abuses, it will get worse. Every one of us individually has to decide what that means, and what we are willing to risk.