The Palestinians Can Defeat Israel In A Street Fight

| Resist!

The global street is where a defenceless oppressed indigenous people have a chance at justice.

(Credit: Flickr / cc / Kevin Van den Panhuyzen)

Palestine has always been the underdog, a country slowly being wiped off the map, a society daily and methodically being dismantled by Israel. As a principally unarmed and oppressed indigenous population, Palestinians are perceived as powerless against the military supremacy of Israel’s technological death industry, persistently outmanoeuvred by Israel’s political cunning and endlessly bullied by a Western world that has made a game of diplomacy and intrigue from our miserable fate.

We’ve lost so much to Israel’s boundless plunder. Over and over, we lose. Home, heritage, life, dignity, security, hope, culture, narrative, orchards and olives, history and artifacts, livelihoods, innocence, language and identity. They’ve excavated our souls, renamed our villages, poured concrete over our ancient cemeteries, made brothels of our churches and mosques, and claimed our hummus, falafel and maqlooba as the traditional food of Jewish foreigners who daily arrive to take our place.

But we’re still here – fighting, dreaming, writing, dancing, painting, loving, having babies – because, as Mahmoud Darwish once said: Hope is not a topic. It’s not a theory. It’s a talent.

And now, nearly 70 years since our demise began, we are finally arriving on the street, the space where we are vastly more powerful than Israel. The global street is where Israel has no real defences against us. Here, Israel is virtually powerless, and they’ve done all they can to keep us off this global street. Israel’s overriding strategy of conquest has always been to keep Palestinian resistance under their purview of power, which exists principally within two realms.

Physical power

The first is physical power. Israel is among the world’s most innovative exporter of death technology – sophisticated hardware, software and terror services which they hone and test on Palestinian bodies and minds. We cannot beat them in military or guerrilla battles, because we have no physical power against such brutality. We tried and we failed on that front.

The second sphere of Israel’s power exists among the powerful elite, the layer of humanity that is motivated and persuaded strictly by power, money and political expediency, such as some heads of state, media bosses, corporate officers, and others who feed off colonialism and vulture capitalism. This is where we’ve been since Oslo, wandering the halls of power, knocking on powerful doors, begging for justice, and in return patronised, blamed, demeaned and manipulated.

Until now, the Palestinian struggle has mostly been waged in these two realms, where we will always be overpowered by Israel’s colonialist malfeasance and pillage. Only once before did we manage to move the Palestinian struggle beyond Israel’s control. It happened during the first intifada. Although our brave young people, armed with rocks, posed no physical threat to the military might of a nuclear state, they managed to turn the tides and shift the power, because for the first time, our struggle reached the global street.

For the first time, ordinary people around the world could see the lie that Israel was fighting an existential war against a dangerous foe. The images and stories of Israeli policy of breaking the bones of rock-throwing children made their way into the living rooms of masses, where discussions of morality were injected into the conversation on Palestine. This was “the street”, the global space of public participation where words like freedom, justice, liberation, resonate. For the first time, media around the world questioned and criticised Israel. The plight of Palestinians was becoming recognised as an indigenous people’s fight for survival against Zionist expansionism and ethnoreligious supremacy.

Thus, the first intifada moved the Palestinian struggle away from Israel’s spheres of power, and planted it firmly in this realm of morality and popular legitimacy. Israel’s decision to then “negotiate” with the PLO was nothing more than a ploy to reposition Palestinian resistance back within their range of control. Until then, Israel had refused to recognise the PLO and did what it could to obliterate them. But then we moved our fight to the streets of the world, exposing the moral dimensions of our struggle.

Israel’s only viable option then was to create a new diplomatic theatre (Oslo Accords) wherein to tuck us once again out of view and off the street, because Israel had no legitimate defence against a native people’s cry for freedom when that cry reached beyond their prison walls and beyond their friends in the elite layers of political and economic power.

Oslo and its ensuing insidious “Peace Process” achieved a great and protracted silence, both from Palestinians and from the world, allowing Israel to continue its original ethnic cleansing programme unimpeded.

The fight over morality

But now we have arrived at another moment of a popular street fight based on morality, legitimacy and justice. The Boycott, Divestment, and Sanctions (BDS) Campaign has shifted the dynamics of power and moved the battle for Palestine once again into the realm of global awareness and public participation in a native people’s struggle for liberation.

Israel’s response has been two fold. They’re employing the tried and tested tactic of negotiations for “interim agreements”. According to a Haaretz report, in addition to “advancing the peace process with the Palestinians [to] stave off a large portion of the boycott threats”, other tactics include “a massive PR campaign against pro-boycott organisations”, filing “legal suits in European and North American courts against organisations that are proponents of the BDS movement”, lobbying for the creation of new laws under which more people can be prosecuted for boycotting Israel, and finally stepping up surveillance of BDS supporters, which would involve operations by the Mossad and Shin Bet.

All of these tactics are meant to silence debate, to intimidate people of conscience and to unravel unified calls for justice. Remarkably, not one of the suggested tactics attempts to put forth a compelling moral counter argument to BDS.

And the reason for that is simple. The spiritual poverty of a colonial state obsessed with creating and maintaining a particular demographic profile does not appeal to popular notions of morality. The assertion of a military state’s security needs in order to justify ongoing destruction of the indigenous population is not convincing in this era of information, where people can see what it looks like to demolish a family’s home whose principle offence is not being Jewish, and know that this happens nearly every day; to see what it looks like to arrest children with slight bodies and fresh urine stains from fear in their pants, and know that there are hundreds more just like them who languish in Israeli jails, tortured, without charge or trial and without access to their parents; to watch videos of terrifying night raids that burst through people’s homes and drag the young and old from their beds, haul them off to a grim fate, and know that this is routine; to read report after report from human rights organisations detailing the terrible minutiae of daily cruelty and humiliation, and know that this is Israeli state policy that has been in effect for decades.

That’s why Israel cannot win this battle, as long as we keep our struggle in this realm of morality. Richard Falk called it a “legitimacy war”. It’s also a global street fight, because justice, legitimacy and liberation do not emerge from negotiations, military occupation, oppression, corporations, or colonial courtrooms. Freedom is almost always borne from the theatre and agony of struggling in the streets.

For Palestinians, who have been fragmented and exiled all over the world, BDS gives us a way to unify and use our tragedy of dislocation to multiply the avenues available to us. It’s an opportunity to welcome and reciprocate the solidarity of people of conscience. It’s a realm to celebrate our native roots and to exercise our talent for hope.

This global street is where a defenceless oppressed indigenous people have a chance at justice. There is nothing for us in negotiations with the powerful elite.

  • Proudscalawag

    DAMN your eyes, you are NOT the indigenes but descendants of imperial colonizers from the seventh century! Jews are the returning indigenes; that truth is catching on!

  • easywriter

    The world has eyes…

  • kevinzeese

    Right those Russian Jews, Zionist Americans and European Jews are the indigenous and the Palestinians who have been there for hundreds of years — and were terrorized out of their homes and continue to be terrorized today — are the colonizers. You have it warped and backward in order to fit it into your Zionist ideology.

  • Proudscalawag

    So were the Jews who were there for thousands of years! Will you argue the Jews became de-indigenized, and how so, at any point? Try arguing that with a First Nations group and see where it goes! Thousands of years beat hundreds, and how much difference does time lapsed make to time of arrival? The reason the Arabs have never accepted ANY offer of real peace is that the power has returned to the natives after the colonizers (or THEIR colonizers, e.g., Ottomans and British) were boss for thirteen centuries. How much time does it take to de-indigenize the natives and to indigenize the colonizers? I dare you to ask that question, without altering the words, to any First Nations/Native American group. Go ahead. I dare you. Seriously.

  • Proudscalawag

    Fact: The Palestinian Arabs are the only people in history that have refused a sovereign state of their own based on a border dispute. In other words, if they can’t have the exact borders they want and all their demands met, they are not interested in a state. Also a fact, they have refused not just once but multiple times over many decades, including approximately 95% of what they said they wanted. Since their demands include things like moving millions of Arabs to the State of Israel in addition to having their own Jew-free state, the conversation is a non-starter. Its time to realize that the Palestinian Arabs aren’t doing Israel a favor by declaring a state. It’s to their own benefit. In the meantime though, because they have squandered all their money on terror and weapons (billions of US and EU taxpayer
    money), they can’t pay their salaries to their workers – and they are mad. Thus, we have a tantrum war.And how is it that Israel can and does have minorities with equal rights under the law, while ‘Palestine’ has to be judenrein?

  • kevinzeese

    Obviously there are indigenous Jews in the region, but that is not who is terrorizing the people who currently live there. The indigenous were the semetic tribes which include Arabs and Jews.So claiming the Jews have a special privilege over the current inhabitants is a false argument.

  • Proudscalawag

    Jews are Jews; one equally so with others. Some returnees (as ‘Jew’ originally meant Judean) are not technically Jewish but they are Hebrews, part of the House of Israel. Such, probably, are the Jews of Ethiopia and other Danites whose descendants have been found in Ghana, Nigeria and even in Zimbabwe! (I didn’t believe that last at first either) Likewise the Bnei Menashe (Manasseh) who have lived in Assam since a few years after the northern kingdom fell in 722 B.C.E. and who are also now returning.
    And tell me: when you’re willing to share an area with more or less equal status for all, but someone else is not–insists on all power in the whole area. and you need it for a refuge, what will you do? Let me remind you Israel has minorities who live in peace and with equal rights stated under the law. We could debate endlessly, and pretty uselessly, how ‘real’ that is or isn’t, but it is there and successful appeals continue to be made to it. The PA insists its land be judenrein and, mostly, Christianrein too. Israel is the one country in the Middle East where the Christian population is actually growing. So–do these facts provide you with a clue or two as to who’s REALLY after special privilege? Think about it..

  • kevinzeese

    Well, I guess we all have a claim on Africa then since that is where all our roots begin.