The Plot To Blame China For COVID-19

| Educate!

Above photo: photoheuristic.info – CC BY 2.0.

The Trump lot—Steve Bannon, Peter Navarro, Mike Pompeo—and their media cheerleaders are as fanatically anti-China as the Biden crew is anti-Russia. Just like George W. Bush’s WMD lies in the early-2000s, there is a developing timeline of Trumpian efforts to bend intelligence on COVID to the administration’s anti-China policy.

Target: China

In the 1980s, the US succeeded in pushing China’s elites to adopt neoliberal market “reforms,” many of which continue to the present. The World Bank hailed China as a “success” story in foreign direct investment, which it says contributed to China’s manufacturing and thus part of its 10 percent GDP growth between most of 1980 to 2010. It was not so successful for the hundreds of millions of Chinese who haven’t breathable air, drinkable water, or health insurance. But that’s another story. China became the “workshop of the world,” assembling parts for wealthier consumers in the US and Europe—until it outsourced that labor to poorer Asian countries. But this exploitation of Chinese labor had the consequence of increasing China’s GDP and its thus power on the world stage. This is known as the “globalization paradox.”

To make sure that China continues to benefit US corporations without getting too big for its boots, the US is relying on the doctrine of “Full Spectrum Dominance”: hypersonic drones, modified stealth bombers, cyberwar, the Space Force, etc., with which to threaten China.

In 2000, an organization to which future-US President George W. Bush belonged, the Project for the New American Century, said that after the US gained “a substantial force presence in the Gulf,” it would take on China: “Raising U.S. military strength in East Asia is the key to coping with the rise of China to great-power status. For this to proceed peacefully, U.S. armed forces must retain their military preeminence and thereby reassure our regional allies.”

But Bush was busy murdering Afghans, Iraqis, Pakistanis, Somalis, and Yemenis as part of the “war on terror.” So, Obama ran with the China ball, announcing a “pivot” to Asia in 2011. In an obvious threat to neighboring China, Japan was pressured to drop the peace clause of constitution, which the US had cynically imposed after nuking Japan in 1945. New US weapons systems were placed in South Korea and the X-37B space weapon (which the US military assured us was not a weapon) was launched, reportedly over the Strait of Taiwan. Then-US Defense Secretary Leon Panetta said that by 2020, he hoped that 60 percent of US ships would be in the South China Sea. The failed Trans-Pacific Partnership deal was an effort to force China’s neighbors to trade and invest on US-dominated regional terms.

But, for the Trump cabal, none of this went far enough. The COVID-19 crisis has given the administration an opportunity to ramp up the anti-China narrative.

The Rogin Cables

A now-deleted statement by the Wuhan Institute of Virology confirms that in early-2018, US officials visited the facility. “The Institute has established close cooperation with a number of well-known U.S. organizations including the National Science Foundation, the EcoHealth Alliance, University of Texas Medical Branch, and the Galveston National Laboratory, and has achieved a series of academic exchanges.” No US concerns about the safety of the lab were made public at the time, including in the press release. But, as we shall see, now we are being told that concerns were raised in private and that the virus escaped from the lab.

In April 2020, MSM subtly started seeding their articles with propaganda. On April 6th, CNN’s Robert Kuznia and Drew Griffin quoted Rutgers University’s Dr. Richard Ebright: “The possibility that the virus entered humans through a laboratory accident cannot and should not be dismissed.”

On April 14th, the Washington Post’s Josh Rogin, a well-known “security” talking head on MSM, was given alleged US Embassy cables dating back to early-2018, purporting to highlight US concerns over safety at the Wuhan Institute of Virology (WIV). One of the cables read: “During interactions with scientists at the WIV …, they noted the new lab has a serious shortage of appropriately trained technicians and investigators needed to safely operate this high-containment laboratory.” Rogin quotes an unnamed US official: “The cable was a warning shot … They were begging people to pay attention to what was going on.”

Citing his Washington Post colleague David Ignatius’s opinion, that the Chinese government’s official story of the virus emerging from a seafood market is “shaky,” Rogin again quotes the unnamed official: “The idea that [it] was just a totally natural occurrence is circumstantial. The evidence it leaked from the lab is circumstantial. Right now, the ledger on the side of it leaking from the lab is packed with bullet points and there’s almost nothing on the other side (sic).” Rogin writes: “There are similar concerns about the nearby Wuhan Center for Disease Control and Prevention lab, which operates at biosecurity level 2, a level significantly less secure than the level-4 standard claimed by the Wuhan Insititute of Virology lab.”

The Washington Post’s claims were echoed by other MSM. On April 16th, CNN Politics reported: “An intelligence official familiar with the government analysis said a theory US intelligence officials are investigating is that the virus originated in a laboratory in Wuhan, China, and was accidentally released to the public.”

Pressuring The Agencies

Lying—along with blackmail, drug-dealing, kidnap, torture, and murder—is the intelligence agencies’ profession. A small sample from the last 20 years alone: Bin Laden linked to 9/11, Iraq linked to Bin Laden, Iraqi WMD, Gaddafi ethnic cleansing in Benghazi, Navy SEALs killed Bin Laden, Syria sarin attack, Russiagate… Former CIA Director and now Secretary of State Mike Pompeo said: “We lied, we cheated, we stole (sic). It’s – it was like – we had entire training courses.”

These agencies need little pressuring in order to lie, yet the fanatically anti-China Trump administration is piling on demands to link the virus to the Wuhan labs.

On April 29th, NBC reported that, like the “war on terror”-era Bush administration in its zeal to link Iraq to 9/11, the Trump administration has been leaning on intelligence agencies. Organizations including the CIA, Defense Intelligence Agency, National Center for Medical Intelligence, and the National Security Agency were ordered by the White House “to comb through communications intercepts, human source reporting, satellite imagery and other data to establish whether China and the World Health Organization initially hid what they knew about the emerging coronavirus pandemic.”

The NYT also reported that Pompeo, “the administration’s most vocal hard-liner on China, has taken the lead in pushing American intelligence agencies for more information, according to current and former officials.”

Trump’s Timeline

The next day (April 30th) at 0916 EDT, the Intelligence Community (IC) issued an unusual press release: “The IC will continue to rigorously examine emerging information and intelligence to determine whether the outbreak began through contact with infected animals or if it was the result of an accident at a laboratory in Wuhan.” By 1141 EDT, media were reporting on the press release.

The timing is important because the anti-Trump MSM are giving the impression that Trump is contradicting the intelligence agencies, when in fact said agencies are sending out signals to their media propagandists to report the virus as potentially originating from a lab.

Later that day at 1625 EDT, Trump told reporters: “You’ve heard three or four different concepts as to how it came out. We should have the answer to that in the not-too-distant future, and that will determine a lot how I feel about China.” A reporter later asked: “have you seen anything at this point that gives you a high degree of confidence that the Wuhan Institute of Virology was the origin of this virus?” Trump replied: “Yes, I have. Yes, I have.”

Another reporter asked: “are you suggesting that maybe you have some evidence that this was not a naturally occurring virus?” Trump replied: “No, we’re going to see where it is. We’re going to see where it comes from. And you know — look, you know every theory, whether you had the theory from the lab, you had the theory from many different — the bats, and the type of bat, and the bat is 40 miles away, so it couldn’t have been here and it couldn’t have been there.” A reporter asked: “what gives you a high degree of confidence that this originated from the Wuhan Institute of Virology?” Trump replied: “I can’t tell you that. I’m not allowed to tell you that.”

Conclusion

Trump’s anti-China rhetoric and actions, including crossing out the prefix “Corona” and replacing it with “China,” are part of a continuation of US empire building that began long before Trump seized power in the Electoral College coup of 2016. The main difference is that where the MSM cheered on Obama’s dangerous and reckless provocations, the majority (with the notable exception of Fox News) are critical of Trump’s methods, though not the ultimate goal of making the Yellow Dragon choke at Uncle Sam’s feet.

T. J. Coles is director of the Plymouth Institute for Peace Research and the author of several books, including Voices for Peace (with Noam Chomsky and others) and  Fire and Fury: How the US Isolates North Korea, Encircles China and Risks Nuclear War in Asia (both Clairview Books).

  • Jeff

    Trump has an irrational hatred for China and Iran, and the BS that the coronavirus came from a Chinese lab is ridiculous. But that said, China is just another evil large country trying to establish an empire. Sorry, no good guys in this story.

  • k.j.noh

    The Chinese have had the longest lasting empire in human history. As empires go, it’s also been mostly remarkably tolerant, multi-cultural, and peaceful: it pioneered the intelligent, secular, tolerant, merit-based systems of administration that astounded and inspired the western enlightenment thinkers. A random example: the last time the Chinese government fired bullets in a war was 1979–over 40 years ago. During the same period, the US has been involved in 27 kinetic wars and invasions, countless military operations, and endless interference in elections, coups, color revolutions–in fact US interference renders democracy around the world largely untenable. Your lazy, misinformed, orientalist attempt at equivalence misses the mark by a country mile.

  • RickW

    Have there ever been “good guys” in Realpolitik? Trump, being the astute businessman he is, wants China to return to the “golden days of yester year” where Western companies could throw their domestic workers under a bus, and set up shop in China for pennies on the dollar. Apparently, it did not occur to these businesses that China would actually seize an advantage from these “pennies” to vie for hegemony status in just 40 short years….

  • Jeff

    That’s not at all true. There has been nothing “tolerant” about the Chinese empire, starting from its inception. In order to create that empire, indigenous people were forced to succumb, and they were killed if they didn’t. The creators of the empire also destroyed much science and Art. And if you think that China is so great, ask a Vietnamese person.

    My statement was not false equivalence. The U.S. is the most powerful and evil empire in the history of the planet. But to paint China as being in any way good is like saying the Democrats are good because they’re not as bad as the Republicans. Who cares? All empires are evil, period, and we should be rejecting these models while seeking another radically different way to live with a lot fewer people (eventually).

  • k.j.noh

    Pardon me, I keep getting the sense that you know don’t know anything about history, empires, or geopolitics. And political and economic systems either. And talking about the Vietnamese, there’s a country that bombed them into the stone age, killed off millions–women. children, babies–, poured agent orange on their land and their genes for generations. Do you want to guess who it was? Hint: it wasn’t the Chinese. I really, really hope you’re not a Vietnam Vet with a terrible conscience who’s been looking to project their sins onto another country, because that’s whom you sound like.

  • Jeff

    So instead of addressing the facts I pointed out or just conceding them, you resort to name-calling and obfuscation. The immense evils committed by the U.S. are irrelevant, we’re talking about China. And no, I’m not a Vietnam vet, I had a high draft lottery and would have refused to go even if I’d been drafted; I was an anti-war protester.

    And BTW, what do you think you know about geopolitics and history that I don’t that’s relevant to this discussion?

  • k.j.noh

    The immense evils–as you admit–committed by the US Empire are far from irrelevant, as you assert. Far from it. They are present, ongoing, and intolerable, and if you were really a genuine antiwar protestor, that’s what you would be focusing on and continuing to protest and challenge. It seems that only an accomplice or beneficiary of such genocides could make such a sweeping, extreme, white-washing statement lacking discernment or conscience. I hope you withdraw your statement.

  • kevinzeese

    This week Margaret Flowers and I examined the escalation of conflict with China. The Trump administration is building on the policies of President Obama and using the COVID-19 virus to escalate conflict — including military conflict with China. Trump wants to divert attention from his failure on the pandemic, but he is creating a potentially bigger problem, military conflict with China. Trump and Biden are trying to be more anti-China than each other so this bi-partisan anti-China policy is getting out of control.

    https://popularresistance.org/pivot-to-peace-must-replace-us-pivot-to-war-with-china/

  • Jeff

    They are irrelevant to this discussion because we’re discussing China; what don’t you get about that? Are you incapable of thinking clearly?

    You sound like a child complaining that because someone else did something, it was OK for you to do it. Not to mention that China and its evils existed well before the U.S. came into existence.

  • k.j.noh

    “They are irrelevant to this discussion because we’re discussing China; what don’t you get about that? Are you incapable of thinking clearly?”

    Thank you, I disagree that this is irrelevant. Not at all. It is totally, completely relevant. The article is about groundless US demonization of China to deflect from its own wrongs. This seems to be very similar to what you are doing. It’s my earnest hope that you might notice this pattern.

    “You sound like a child complaining that because someone else did something, it was OK for you to do it. Not to mention that China and its evils existed well before the U.S. came into existence.”

    It’s interesting to note that mentioning genocidal war–the wars in Vietnam, Laos, Cambodia–that you still refuse to acknowledge and address–and have benefited from–is, in your mind, a child’s complaint? Bravo. That’s an elision I associate with a deeply guilty conscience.

    As for the lazy, blanket, “they are all evil” mantra, please be so kind as to reference something “evil” the Chinese have done that even approximates what the US has done in the past 50 years. I think we can agree that critical thinking requires the capacity to discern and make meaningful distinctions.

    And please, if you could, I humbly request that you provide real sources, not some jaundiced propaganda, anecdote, misinformation, rantings that you seem to have imbibed wholesale and indiscriminately from within the pin-prick camera obscura of a reactionary world view.

    And while we’re at it, setting the record straight, may I make the request that you please consider returning the real estate you own to the indigenous tribes that were slaughtered off by the state, so you could have a platform and the leisure to broadcast your privileged, primitive-accumulation-derived, antinomian, anti-state views?

  • Richard

    Our government can blame whoever they want for the virus, but they might as well have started it themselves because of their inaction’s for at least 4 months that we know of. I have always said that our government is our worst enemy bar none, this is simply more proof to add to the stack. For the life of me I just don’t understand my fellow countrymen buying into their BS and continuing to support them no matter what they do, including their own demise.

  • bccarver

    so not you are promoting the bombing of pipelines, ignoring the catastrophic result of spilling thousands of liters into the environment. Gawd you are a fucking moron.