Trump Executive Order Makes Border Crisis Worse

| Educate!

Above Photo: Thien/Flickr

Note: Advocates for immigrant rights should not consider President Trump’s executive order on detaining immigrant children to be a victory. Now the Trump administration will lock up entire families. This is still an immoral violation of the human rights of immigrants.

The Trump executive order returns the United States to the abusive policies of the Obama era who also incarcerated entire families. There were outcries of protests then and litigation resulted in an agreement to stop the indefinite detention of immigrant families.

Sarah Lazare writes about the incarceration of immigrant families in In These Times describing the reaction to the same policy in the Obama era, writing

“In August 2016, 22 mothers incarcerated in ‘Berks Family Residential Center’ with their children wrote a letter to Jeh Johnson—then Secretary of DHS—stating, ‘Our children, who range in age from 2 to 16, have been deprived of a normal life. We are already traumatized from our countries of origin. We risked our own lives and those of our children so we could arrive on safe ground.’

“‘While here our children have considered committing suicide, made desperate from confinement,’ they continued. ‘The teenagers say that being here, life makes no sense. One of our children said he wanted to break the window to jump out and end this nightmare.’”

Immigration laws in the United States do not work and the Congress is too dysfunctional to fix them. Immigrants are scapegoats for a failed economic policy that leaves most people in the United States economically insecure. Among the policies that undermine the economy are corporate trade agreements that serve transnational corporations not the people or planet, the hollowing out of the US industrial base and lack of investment in fundamental necessities for the economy, e.g. infrastructure, education. The mis-investment of tax dollars with more than half of US discretionary spending going to the military hollows out the base of the US economy. US foreign policy that results in militarism and regime change putting in place dictatorial regimes that do not serve their people results in people needing to escape to safer countries These fundamental errors have created a failed economic policy that creates widespread economic insecurity that will not be corrected by incarcerating immigrant families or by a trade war.  KZ

Jailing families is not a solution

WASHINGTON — President Trump has signed an executive order mandating that families be jailed by the U.S. Departments of Homeland Security or Defense. This order will likely have the effect of jailing, for months or even years, immigrant families seeking safety in the U.S. The National Immigration Law Center has long decried the practice of jailing immigrant families, filing lawsuits when necessary to defend their rights. Below is a statement from Marielena Hincapié, executive director of the National Immigration Law Center, who visited family detention facilities in 2014:

“The Trump administration has created a crisis and committed horrific human rights abuses by separating children from their parents at the border. Clearly on the defense, today it used a political sleight of hand to try to placate Americans who have been rightly outraged by their government’s repugnant policies, including separating children and babies from their parents and housing them in cages.

“Jailing families is not an acceptable solution to putting children in cages. The best — and safest — place for these children is with their families and in their communities. The Trump administration pretends that alternatives to detention don’t exist. This is false. There are numerous alternatives that are both more humane and less costly, but this president refuses to use them. Our country has a system in place to process asylum claims, and these families should be allowed to go through this legal process.

“The Trump administration may not care much for the basic constitutional rights of people seeking safety. We do, and we’ll work with communities and in courtrooms to protect them. Not a single one of us should be standing on the sidelines as this administration inflicts lifelong trauma on these children. It is up to all of us to hold this administration accountable and stop this nightmare.”

  • Niemand

    So nobody’s going to mention that Trump has stopped the tearing-babies-from-their-mothers’-arm-and-locking-them-in-dungeons treatment?

  • kevinzeese

    He solved a horrible problem he created and said he could not solve. Now, he created a new problem, incarcerating families which he hopes will be indefinite detentions. That is not much to brag about.

  • Apparently you didn’t read the article.

  • Niemand

    I did, though. Where in there does it say he stopped?

  • Niemand

    Kevin, in a grad-school psych class, the professor, a well-respected psychiatrist, pointed out a common, dishonest ploy that corrupts both discourse and thinking. He called it the “never give a ***** an even break”.

    The way it works is that someone decides, a priori, to criticise some person for being, not for their actions.

    Thus, if the deprecated individual does something with bad intentions but it unexpectedly produces an improved result, criticise the intention. If the individual has an epiphany and acts with good intentions for once, but it produces a bad result, criticise the result. Never give credit, because to deprecated individuals it’s never due.

    Trump stopped the separating. But, true to the NGA*AEB principle, he gets no credit. He was, is, and will always be in the wrong, About everything. Forever.

    It’s like Clinton or Obama worship, but in reverse.

  • tibetan cowboy

    Ignorance is bliss, and very all-american, sorry to say.

  • Niemand

    Well, where?

  • rgaura

    Good documentary on Hutto; note at about 4 and a half minutes, it is Chertoff who kicks off the policy, the guy who made billions from the government for his Israeli made TSA machines that harass and cause cancer for travellers at airports, and do nothing to prevent terrorism. My favorite quote from the movie; they pay $200 a day for every man woman and child incarcerated, it would be cheaper to put them up at the Hilton!
    These are multi billion dollars theft of taxpayer monies, they solve no problems, only create oppressive bureaucracies and opportunities for violations of human rights. There are alternatives.

  • rgaura