Above: Iranian students confront police at the University of Tehran during a demonstration on December 30, 2017. (Photo by AFP)
We are closely following the protests in Iran, which seem to have begun as protests about the Iranian economy. They have evolved into protests favoring regime change and urging Iran to stop protecting the Palestinian people and its involvement in Lebanon and Syria. An article by Moon of Alabama, which we republished, raises the question of whether these protests are being manipulated by the United States and Israel as a color revolution regime change strategy. That is still an open question and one for which we are seeking evidence.
Reuters reports that a small percentage of protesters are using the demonstrations to raise foreign policy issues. Another Reuters report described increasing violence by protesters, leading to a strong response by Iranian authorities. Associated Press reported that nine protesters were killed, including some who tried to storm a police station to take weapons. Iranian state television puts the death toll in six days of demonstrations to at least 20 people. These reports are reminiscent of how the Arab Spring protests in Syria became violent and were the seeds of the bloody Syrian civil war.
Author Max Blumental pointed out the similarity between the Syrian escalation and the escalation in Iran, tweeting:
“Armed protesters” in Iran attacked police stations and tried to overrun military bases. Hard to imagine the same external forces that pushed an armed insurgency against the Syrian state aren’t licking their chops at these developments. https://t.co/PFFMtmJR3C
— Max Blumenthal (@MaxBlumenthal) January 1, 2018
Both President Trump and Prime Minister Netenyahu applauded the Iranian protesters. Trump is calling for regime change and Netenyahu is calling it a fight for freedom. Russia described the protests as being fueled by external forces, according to the Times of Israel. The Turkish Foreign Ministry urged protesters to avoid violence and not to fall for “provocations.”
Tass reported on Russia’s Foreign Ministry’s description of the protests, writing, “This is Iran’s internal affair. We express the hope that the situation won’t develop under the scenario of bloodshed and violence.” Further the Foreign Ministry stressed, “External interference destabilizing the situation is inadmissible.”
Iran’s Supreme Leader Ayatollah Ali Khamenei said on television, “In the events of recent days, the enemies have united and are using all their means, money, weapons, policies and security services to create problems for the Islamic regime,” adding “The enemy is always looking for an opportunity and any crevice to infiltrate and strike the Iranian nation.”
On Twitter, some observers are pointing out that photos claiming to be of the protest are not really from Iranian protests:
1) is from a film
2) is actually in Bahrain
3) is actually in Buenos Aires
4) is a pro government rallyIt’s not a mistake. pic.twitter.com/e0z3UIYcEt
— tankie jack? (@jxckhy) January 2, 2018
Reportedly 450 people have been arrested in three days of protests and the courts are threatening to treat them harshly. Arrested protesters could potentially face death penalty cases when they come to trial, the head of Tehran’s Revolutionary Court has reportedly warned. “Obviously one of their charges can be Moharebeh,” or “waging war against God”, the semi-official Tasnim news agency quoted Mousa Ghazanfarabadi as saying.
President Hassan Rouhani has acknowledged the public’s anger over the Islamic Republic’s flagging economy, though he and others warned that the government wouldn’t hesitate to crack down on those it considers lawbreakers, according to the Independent.
While Western media is reporting massive protests, people in Iran are reporting a different perspective like this series of tweets by Sayed Mousavi, an Islamic Culture & Communications Student:
SPREAD IT!
Short visual roundup of a handful of exactly what Mainstream Media, overnight
“Iran Twitter experts” aren’t so interested in showing you
A few examples of aspects in the #Iranprotests that are simply ignoredAll images from one day:
31st December 2017Long Live Iran https://t.co/wDaRwgfwwS
— Sayed Mousavi ???? (@SayedMousavi7) December 31, 2017
While legitimate grievances & protest exist over internal issues in Iran, some of Twitter’s “Iran analysts” are truly getting over exited. So let’s open the issue up a little bit, who’s in the streets, how large exactly are the crowds & who’s joining them…
Thread#IranProtest pic.twitter.com/8qcEifyr8V
— Sayed Mousavi ???? (@SayedMousavi7) January 1, 2018
The protests have been going on for three days. It started in Mashhad in a protest by people who had lost their savings due to the closing & bankruptcy of some financial institutions, known as the “Caspian Affair”. pic.twitter.com/qEUdhyOb63
— Sayed Mousavi ???? (@SayedMousavi7) January 1, 2018
As a few similar protests took place in other cities & in a quick turn of events, some groups started slogans & protests about other issues, such as regime change, monarchy etc …
— Sayed Mousavi ???? (@SayedMousavi7) January 1, 2018
Seeing opportunity & with the help of social media apps like Telegram, these marginal groups started organizing. This was almost done solely by one single Telegram channel, a foreign based & suspicious “AmadNews”. pic.twitter.com/rcRDKbz3jw
— Sayed Mousavi ???? (@SayedMousavi7) January 1, 2018
What is interesting however is that the aggressiveness of the protest organizers has clearly led to a backlash. Some figures from the reformist camp, the traditional opposition in Iran that shaped the 2009 election riots, have condemned the riots.
— Sayed Mousavi ???? (@SayedMousavi7) January 1, 2018
After two days, no protest of considerable size has developed in Tehran. This is a very important signal of how protests will continue & how important they are for a vast group of people in the Iranian mainstream. pic.twitter.com/YN47O2ycSx
— Sayed Mousavi ???? (@SayedMousavi7) January 1, 2018
Imho,based on the videos & images, a maximum of no more than 500 ppl have rallied in the recent protests in Tehran. I seriously don’t get why Western regime change hawks are so optimistic & happy.I couldn’t find a video showing more than 500.See the 2009 report again if u need 2! pic.twitter.com/wKhYarHr40
— Sayed Mousavi ???? (@SayedMousavi7) January 1, 2018
Based on the dozens of videos & images I’ve seen from opposition sources, protests in cities other than the aforementioned gatherings (with about 500-1000 demonstrators) amass usually between 50 to 300 protesters. Do the research & see the vids…everything is on the net
— Sayed Mousavi ???? (@SayedMousavi7) January 1, 2018
The #Iranprotests are a peculiar thing.History shows big protests usually happen in Iran when a clear & specific issue lays the basis for a common view of injustice taking place (ex. 2009 election protests)this time round,no specific unifying issue/clear objective has been cited.
— Sayed Mousavi ???? (@SayedMousavi7) January 1, 2018
From social media vids, seems the cities of Karaj, Ahwaz, Kermanshah, Masjid Suleiman, Rasht & Izehh witnessed crowds above the 500 mark, between 500 to 2000. That makes it 7 cities with protests above 500.
— Sayed Mousavi ???? (@SayedMousavi7) January 1, 2018
This is a developing story with conflicting reports making it hard to understand what is really going on. As a result, it is one we will continue to monitor and report on.