The True Origins Of Mutual Aid And Danger Of Getting It Wrong
There is a conversation happening on social media, in organizing circles, in group chats and comment sections about what mutual aid is, what it can do, and whether it is failing. But it is, in my view, asking the wrong question.
The question is not whether mutual aid works. It does. It has, for centuries. The better question is whether mutual aid, as most people currently practice it, can reliably function as a long-term welfare system for entire communities. My answer is no— not by itself. Not without structure.
This essay is my attempt to lay out what I mean by that. I want to trace where mutual aid actually comes from.